
In a lawsuit filed in an Ohio trial court on September 10, 2010, VaNeisha Robinson, a nineteen (19) year-old resident of Akron, claims that, approximately five (5) years ago, she purchased a box of stuffed animals at a garage sale, for $5.00. After she returned home with the box, Ms. Robinson noticed a LeBron James pendant inside the box. Although the pendant is diamond encrusted, Ms. Robinson believed that it was fake “costume jewelry,” and for the next five (5) years, thought it was worthless. Ms. Robinson, out of curiosity, recently decided to have the pendant appraised, and was told that it was worth $9,670.00. On June 16, 2010, she listed the pendant for sale on eBay. The listing was apparently unsuccessful, so Ms. Robinson contacted the media with her story. The story made its way to Katherine Powers (mother of Maverick Carter, CEO of LeBron James’ marketing company), who then contacted Ms. Robinson, and told Ms. Robinson that she would make an offer that she (Ms. Robinson) “could not refuse.” Ms. Powers also promised Ms. Robinson that she would meet LeBron James.
On July 14, 2010, Ms. Robinson, her mother, sister and friend arrived at Ms. Powers’ house. Ms. Robinson and her mother (who happened to be friendly with Ms. Powers from church) went inside, and the others remained in the vehicle. Ms. Robinson was surprised when eight (8) or nine (9) other individuals, along with Ms. Powers, were waiting. Ms. Robinson claims she felt threatened, and went to the car to retrieve her friend and sister. Upon returning to Ms. Powers’ house, Ms. Robinson checked her phone and realized that someone had purchased the pendant from her eBay listing. When Ms. Robinson informed Ms. Powers of this, she was confronted and was told she could not sell the pendant, because it belonged to Ms. Powers.
Due to there being several angry persons inside the house, Ms. Robinson requested that Ms. Powers accompany her outside. Ms. Robinson then gave her friend the pendant to take outside to the vehicle. At that point, two unknown individuals blocked the vehicle in the driveway and prevented Ms. Robinson and her party from leaving. One of the individuals went back inside, and informed Ms. Robinson’s mother, who was still inside, that she “ain’t going nowhere.” Apparently, due to yelling and screaming, a neighbor called the police. Plaintiff’s mother then told her to hand over the pendant, because “it was not worth getting hurt over.” Ms. Robinson, fearing for her safety, reluctantly did so, and was then permitted to leave.
Ms. Robinson sued Ms. Powers and Mr. Carter, alleging false imprisonment, for detaining her at the Powers home against her will, theft of the pendant in violation of Ohio state law, replevin (to obtain possession of the pendant) and intentionally inflicting Ms. Robinson with emotional distress.
Continue Reading...